|
|
Posted by FatKat on 10/17/13 11:27
D.E. wrote:
> "FatKat" <robynari@juno.com> schreef in bericht
> news:1127427610.641854.238920@o13g2000cwo.googlegroups.com...
> >
> > Amun wrote:
> >> "FatKat" <robynari@juno.com> wrote in message
> >> news:1127355874.925156.176270@f14g2000cwb.googlegroups.com...
> >> > Hardly a justification. Being the owner of something means you can not
> >> > only set the price, but also decide whether to sell or not. If I
> >> > decide to steal a car, the fact that the owner hadn't put it on the
> >> > market doesn't change the fact that I've just taken a car that isn't
> >> > mine. There are many compelling arguments for distinguishing file
> >> > sharing from theft, but this is not one of them. Also, simply being
> >> > out of print (thought they had a different term) doens't mean out of
> >> > circulation - old record stores, individual collectors, E*bay offer a
> >> > few of the avenues for obtaining hard-to-find music.
> >> >
> >> So if someone buys a used record from an old record store or ebay or just
> >> downloads a copy off the net or gets and mp3 made.
> >
> > Is that a question? Sounds like you're asking what the difference is
> > between DL'g an MP3 or just buying it used. Assuming that's what
> > you're asking. then see above - when you buy an old album, you're
> > buying what somebody else sold. The seller once bought that copy of
> > "Kilroy was Here" and now sold it - trading his "license" to listen to
> > that music for money.
>
> Hahha
hahahaha
You probbaly work for a dentist, right?
> not in my country, I could copy the CD keep thje copy and sell the
> original again.
Gee, let's all pack our bags and move to the Netherlands. Wowwwww
> Totally legal. I am in sch a great country.
>
Sounds like a song. A shitty song - maybe you can sell it to
advertising. Make sure you got plenty of that laughing in it.
>
> > There is still one copy of that album in
> > circulation. DL/UL music is different - the seller probably purchased
> > the music, but is now churning out copies of it. I doubt that RIAA
> > would have an issue (a legit one anyway) if people were just ripping
> > their own music, but P2P proves that this isn't the case.
>
> So radio stations are distributing songs, hmmm . ;o)
No, they're just broadcasting music - it doesn't become something
that's actually distributed until you find a way to record it and keep
it independent of the broadcast.
Navigation:
[Reply to this message]
|