Posted by Doc on 12/05/06 17:20

Roy W. Rising wrote:

> Further, Klay Anderson wrote here "It was ALL track; she would only do
> *one* take.

It occurred to me this makes no sense. If she would only do one take
and go with whatever the results were, she might as well do it live,
which I believe she did.

To be honest, the "timing errors" you cite don't strike me as
compelling evidence at all. I just don't think she could have matched
the various nuances and releases so precisely.

> I
> have the feeling he was "there" or knew someone who was.

Except he never did clarify how he "knew" this. And "knowing someone
who was there" as opposed to personally eyeball witnessing something
severely cuts credibility/reliability. Hearsay evidence and all.

[Back to original message]