Posted by Roy L. Fuchs on 12/31/05 21:27

On Sat, 31 Dec 2005 21:16:30 GMT, spam@uce.gov (Bob) Gave us:

>On Sat, 31 Dec 2005 19:39:55 GMT, Roy L. Fuchs
><roylfuchs@urfargingicehole.org> wrote:
>
>>>The OP claimed that the active layer was on
>>>top, not in the middle.
>
>> No, I did not, nor did the OP.
>
>For purposes of this discussion, YOU are the one I refer to as the OP.

AND AGAIN. I NEVER said anything about it being ON the top. I have
ALWAYS stated that it was just under the top coat/top side of the
disc. You could not, in a million years, quote a post where I said it
was on top, because I ACTUALLY know how they are constructed, whereas
YOU were guessing the whole time.
>
>
>I said it was just under the top
>>coat. Also, I would contend that that web site has flaws in their
>>interpretation as well, because they do not laminated a polycarbonate
>>layer onto the top side.
>
>I am talking about the Fuji MIJ DVD YUDEN000 T02 sikver lacquer discs.

Waaaahhh... You were wrong, and now you backpedal.


>I broke one and it is made of two polycarbonate sheets of the same
>apparent thickness, with the active material in the middle.
>
>> You were drunk then, because I never said that it was on the top,
>>nor did the OP.
>
>Ad homs are not going to change the fact that you were and still are
>wrong. The active material is sandwiched between two polycarbonate
>sheets.

On a production disc. NOT on a recordable. Want to bet?

>I broke one and saw it for myself. Now you need to obtain a Fuji MIJ
>DVD YUDEN000 T02 sikver lacquer disc and see for yourself.

You should join a circus. Oh... wait... you already have! Do you
work with Max?

>> So, your argument was based on a guess the whole time, even though
>>you claimed to have done scratch tests.
>
>I was deceived by the antireflective coating they put on the bottom.

There is no coating on the bottom of a disc. There IS a polycarb
plate. It is clear and uncoated.

>
>>>Therefore the OP's claim that the active material is on the top is
>>>WRONG.
>
>> I would like to see the quote of that post.
>
>YOU are the OP in this discussion.

Yes, and I never made that claim, dipshit. Stop lying, and I'll
stop insulting you. It's that simple, Max.

>

[Back to original message]