|
|
Posted by Specs on 10/05/18 11:38
"Ty Ford" <tyreeford@comcast.net> wrote in message
news:MPSdndegYrd7tUfeRVn-qA@comcast.com...
> On Thu, 26 Jan 2006 16:17:20 -0500, David McCall wrote
> (in article <A%aCf.5569$Jn1.2025@trndny01>):
>
> >
> > "Ty Ford" <tyreeford@comcast.net> wrote in message
> > news:ieqdncOpo7gIt0TeRVn-tg@comcast.com...
> >>
> >> There's a big difference between HDV and HD video. Try a swish pan or
> >> shoot a
> >> basketball game and find out for yourself.
> >>
> SNIP
> >
> > I have not played with HDV so you might be talking about blockyness
> > and other image artifacts like you get with most heavily compressed
> > formats, and the solution remains as above.
> >
> > David
>
> Exactly. The misguided premise that HDV is as good as true HD, which
surfaces
> here periodically is just plain wrong. That's my point.
>
> Ty Ford
>
To my knowledge that assertion has NEVER been made on this group. How do
you define TRUE HD? That phrase is utter nonsense anyway because there as
so many variations of HD in use, all quite different, that defining "true
HD" would be futile. I've never heard anyone describe SD formats as being
"True SD" regardless of compression scheme used.
In our own tests we have blown several of the misconceptions of HDV
including the ability to pull a key, the ability to accurately track
features or even survive the post production process at all. In fact
earlier this week we had some HDV footage shot by a DoP friend of ours and
put it through our matchmoving software . We produced a rock solid camera
track without any difficulty at all. Another misconception blown apart.
I question your motivation to keep posting "HDV is not real HD" when you
offer no evidence to the contrary. I have never used HDV professionally but
have seen enough to know it is a valid format just like DV was before it.
What surfaces on this group periodically by a select few, including Ty Ford,
is nothing more than eliteist snobbery reminiscent of the day that DV was
introduced. If you don't like it TY don't use it. Just stop posting
ingorant groundless rubbish you are a stuck record.
Get over yourselves HDV has the ability to produce absolutely stunning
images in the right hands.
Navigation:
[Reply to this message]
|