|
|
Posted by Roy L. Fuchs on 06/22/06 04:20
On Wed, 21 Jun 2006 20:40:17 GMT, Jeff Rife <wevsr@nabs.net> Gave us:
>Joshua Zyber (joshzyber@comcast.net) wrote in alt.video.dvd:
>> > Going to a forum where there are opinions from both sides of the
>> > fanbase is not as enlightening as going to a non-biased review
>>
>> Your logic astounds me. By your reasoning, hearing opinions from both
>> sides of the argument is less helpful than reading heavily biased
>> articles likely paid for by one of those sides? Fascinating.
>
>It does seem weird to me, too. Even he thinks AVS Forum has opinions on
>both sides of the issue. And if both sides are represented, then if the
>BD-1000P were significantly better than (or even as good as) the HD-A1,
>there would be a *lot* of people saying just that.
And we won't even mention a comparison with the HD-XA1! ;-]
>
>Since it's clear from AVS Forum posts that the first Blu-Ray player isn't
>worth the $1,000 price tag, and that the first HD-DVD player is a better
>deal, either everybody there is an HD-DVD shill, or the BD-1000P just isn't
>that good.
So, just where are those comparisons to the flagship Toshiba player?
The HD-XA1???
> When you go back and look at previous posts where people tout
>how much better Blu-Ray will be, and now turn an about face when they get
>the actual player and movies, that says that even the Blu-Ray supporters
>are disappointed, which is a bad, bad sign for the format.
OOoooopps! Looks like my secret midnight hexes are working... ;-]
Navigation:
[Reply to this message]
|